K.M. Randall | The Official Author Site
Picture

Realism v. Fantasy in YA

6/1/2015

 
Picture
From a reader and observer's standpoint, magic, vampires, angels, and witches have been hot trends and themes since the dawn of Harry Potter and Twilight. In came the era of fantasy and paranormal geared for young adult readers. Meanwhile, us OLDER "young adults," who'd long been searching for romances between teen vamps and vastly vivid magical world-building suddenly had just as vast of a selection of books to choose from.

As a reader who has been reading fantasy my entire life, it was amazing to have so many new titles and wonderous stories. And of course, it's been helpful to have launched my writing career in a time when the kind of books and stories I like writing are popular, in literature but also in television and movies.

So the point of this post ... A recent article in the Irish Times made the statement that fantasy in YA may be on its way out in 2015, making room for stories centered around more realistic themes. Now, while the author admits it's a sweeping generalization, I still felt the need to argue the point, specifically because of the reasons the author, Robert Dunbar, gives for this prediction in Realism Replaces Fantasy in Young Adult Fiction:

"Traumas and tantrums, often arising from clashes with various authority figures, remain a feature of the “growing up” process, but in the more accomplished novels they are seen as providing the opportunity for enhancing inter-generational understanding rather than merely creating an excuse for prolonged outbursts of shouting." 
The writer of the article then goes on to mention two books, both of which explore elements of homosexuality, and the deeply moving adolescent experiences that are involved in these books. I'm not questioning his analysis, I'm sure they're quite deep. But in the midst of all that, fantasy in YA still has a place. Harry Potter himself dealt with insecurity, loss, bullying, child abuse, discordant friendships, consequences, and the sacrifice that comes with choosing to be a leader in a world of followers. These books were not just so wildly popular because of the amazing world and epic battle JK Rowling created, they also resonated on a human level. 

Many YA fantasy books delve into heavier themes, including homosexuality, suicide, shifting parental relationships, abuse ... So my response to this article is no, realism is not going to be replacing fantasy in the YA genre in 2015. I think there's plenty of room for both. And often, they can be one in the same. 
0 Comments

    Author

    K.M. Randall writes fantasy and paranormal for both a general and young adult audience. Her debut novel, an epic fantasy called Fractured Dream, launched in June 2014, and her second book, The Reaper's Daughter, launched May 2015. Randall also published Fairytale Lost, a prequel to Fractured Dream, as an exclusive on Wattpad. She blogs about dreams, female heroines, and activism and its relevancy to the literary and fictional world. And when in the season, sometimes she just likes to talk about Halloween. She is currently hard at work on the second book in the Dreamer Saga series, Shattered World. 

    Subscribe to K.M. Randall - Blog by Email

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    Follow on Bloglovin
    Fractured Dream (The Dreamer Saga)

    Archives

    February 2022
    February 2019
    December 2017
    November 2017
    March 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    November 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    September 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012

    Categories

    All
    2016
    2016 Reading Lists
    3-day Sale
    99 Cents
    "A"
    Abbadon
    Action
    Activism
    Adam's Family
    Adolescence
    Adolescence In Literature
    Adventure
    Afterlife
    Anne Rice
    Anubis
    Aprons
    ARC Readers
    A Room Of My Own
    Atropos
    Audio
    Author
    Author Interview
    Author Marketing
    Axis Trilogy
    Bad Ass Heroines
    Bad Santa
    Balance
    Batman
    Bats
    Becoming A Mom
    Beetlejuice
    Belief
    Belle
    Big Bad Wolves
    Blogging
    Blog Hop
    Blog Tour
    Book Blast
    Book Blitz
    Book Collector
    Book Covers
    Book Deals
    Book Editing
    Book Hoarders
    Book Hoarding
    Book I Of The Dreamer
    Book Launc
    Book Reviews
    Books
    Book Sale
    Book Sharing
    Book Tour
    Book Trailer
    Book Trailers
    Booktrope
    Booktrope Closing
    Booktrope Publishing
    Boyfriends
    Boy Vs. Girl
    Broken Heart
    Buffy The Vampire Slayer
    Bunnicula
    Cait Reynolds
    Camelot
    Caroline B. Cooney
    Carrie Fisher
    Castle Battle
    Cellar Door Lit Rants And Reviews
    Change
    Changes
    Charles DiLaurentis
    Chicklit
    Children
    Children's Books
    Children's Lit
    Chirrut Imwe
    Chris Hemsworth
    Christmas
    Christmas Presents
    Christopher Pike
    Cinder
    Cinderella
    CINDY
    Classics
    Cleaning
    Clutch
    College Dreams
    Comic-Con
    Contemporary Women's Lit
    Copyright Infringement
    Costume Ideas
    Crafts
    Crafts For Kids
    Creative Non-fiction
    Cyrborgs
    Dancing
    Darth Vader
    Deals
    Death
    Death Deities
    Death Star
    Decor
    Decorating
    Decorations
    Defining
    Deities
    Demeter
    Diaries
    Dislike Button
    Disney
    Disney Princesses
    Dogs
    Doll House
    Downcast
    Dragon Moon Press
    Dragons
    Dream Diary
    Dreams
    Dystopian
    Eddie Justice
    Editing
    Egyptian God
    Election
    Elena Kincaid
    Elf On The Shelf
    Elsa
    English
    Epic Fantasy
    Erotica
    Escapism
    Eternal LIfe
    Excerpt
    Facebook
    Facebook Launch Party
    Facebook Pet Peeves
    Fae
    Fairies
    Fairytale Lost
    Fairytale Retelling
    Fairytales
    Fairy Tales
    Faith
    Fandom
    Fandom Terminology
    Fangirl
    Fantasy
    Fantasy Art
    Fantasycon
    Fantasy Fiction
    Fantasy-Fiction
    Felicity Jones
    Feminism
    Feminists
    First Love
    Fisher Price Little People
    Fitness
    Flash Fiction
    Flip The Flap Books
    Florida
    Force Awakens
    Fractured Dream
    Fractured Dream Soundtrack
    Free Books
    Freyja
    Friendship
    Frozen
    Gandalf
    Gay Rights
    Gener Roles
    Getting Older
    Ghosts
    Ghost Stories
    Girl Power
    Giveaway
    Giveaways
    Goals
    Go Ask Alice
    Greek Mythology
    Greek Myths
    Grim Reaper
    Grim's Fall
    Grim's Fall: Part III
    Growing Apart
    Growth
    Hades
    Haiku
    Halloween
    Harry Potter
    Health
    Heartbreak
    Hero
    Heroine
    Heroines
    Hindu Deities
    Hindu Gods
    Holly Black
    Home Office
    Homosexual Themes
    Hope
    Horror
    Horror High
    House Of Night
    Human Rights
    Humble Bundle
    Ideas
    Ignorance
    Imaginary Friends
    Imagination
    Indigo-Ashe Book Trailers
    Inner Voice
    Inspiration
    Inspiring Women
    Insta-love
    International Women's Day
    Invisible Friends
    Irish Times
    Jackie Paper
    Jake And The Neverland Pirates
    Jayme Beddingfield
    Jyn Erso
    K-2SO
    Kali
    Katrina Mendolera
    Katrina M. Mendolera
    Katrina M. Randall
    Katrina Randall
    Kickstarter
    Kids
    Kindness
    K.m. Randall
    K.M. Randall
    KM Randall
    K. Williams
    Kylo Ren
    Larry WIlson
    Legends
    Leia
    Library
    Life After Death
    Lingo
    Literary Characters
    Literature
    Little Boys
    Little Girls
    Little Red Riding Hood
    LJ Smith
    Lord Of The Rings
    Losing Friends
    Louise Cooper
    Love
    Love Triangles
    Lunar Chronicles
    Magic
    Magics
    Making A Book Trailer
    Marissa Meyer
    Mark Zuckerberg
    Mary-sue
    Mermaid Summer
    Mexican Day Of The Dead
    Mexican Folk Saint
    Miley Cyrus
    Moms
    Monday Blogs
    Motherhood
    Mrs. Piggle Wiggle
    Music
    Muslims
    My First Superman Books
    My Son
    Mythology
    Myths
    National Tell A Fairytale Day
    New Roads
    New Year
    Norse
    Occult
    October Frights Blog Hop
    Olympus Falling
    Omar Mateen
    One Flew Over The Cukoos Nest
    Orlando
    OTP
    Ouija Board
    Paranormal
    Parenthood
    Parents
    Part II
    Paul And Mary
    Peppa Pig
    Perceptions
    Persephone
    Personal Growth
    Peter
    Peter Yarrow
    PLL Theories
    Poems
    Poetry
    Poetry About Children
    Prequel
    Pretty Little Liars
    Pretty Little Liar Theories
    Publishing
    Publishing Industry
    Puff The Magic Dragon
    Quirky Book Sirens
    Rafflecopter
    Rafflecopter Giveaway
    Rant
    Rap Battles
    Rasputina
    Reading
    Reading For Life
    Realism
    Reality
    Reality TV
    Reapers
    Rebel
    Rebellions
    Refurbishing Dollhouse
    Relationships
    Release Date
    Repurposing
    Research
    Resistance
    Resolutions
    Restaurants
    Retelling
    Retellings
    Review
    Reviews
    Rey
    Richie Tankersley Cusick
    R.L. Stine
    RL Stine
    Rogue One
    Rogue One Review
    Romance
    Ruby Dawson Saga
    Running
    Rylee Adamson
    Sale
    Santa
    Santa Clause
    Santa Muerte
    Sara Douglass
    School Dreams
    Science-fiction
    Secret Circle
    Serving
    Sex
    Sexual Content
    Sharing Meaning
    Shattered World
    Sheilah Randall
    Shipping
    Short Story
    Sir Edwin Arnold
    Siren Publishing
    Sisters
    Skepticism
    Slices Of Mommy's Life
    Snow White
    Social Media
    Songs
    Soul Mates
    Soundtrack
    Speculative Fiction
    Spooky
    Star Wars
    Stephen King
    Stop The Hate
    Strong Female Characters
    Strong Females
    Superheroes
    Super Heroes
    Superman
    Supernatural
    Sword
    Symbolism
    Tarod
    Teenage Friendships
    Teenagers
    Teen Horror
    Teen WItch
    The Craft
    The Darkest Part Of The Forest
    The Dreamer Saga
    The Dreamer Trilogy
    The Golden Fiddle
    The Grim's Fall
    The Highly Capable
    The Last Jedi
    The Lemonade Trick
    The Reaper's Daughter
    The Reaper's Daughter
    The Reape's Daughter
    The Shadow Soul
    Thor
    Three Fates
    Time Master Trilogy
    Toddler Books
    Tolkien
    Trailokya Trilogy #1
    Transylvania Concubine
    Tressla
    True Love
    Twilight
    Twisted Fairytales
    Twitter Blast
    Underworld
    Unshattered
    Valentine's Day
    Vampire
    Vampire Diaries
    VC Andrews
    Vlog
    Voices
    Waitressing
    Wattpad
    Web Series
    Who Is A?
    Wicca
    Witches
    Witch Week
    Woman Power
    Women
    Women In Lit
    Women In Movies
    Women's Rights
    Wonderwoman
    Wonder Woman
    Workaholic
    Writing
    YA
    Young Adult

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    2016
    2016 Reading Lists
    3-day Sale
    99 Cents
    "A"
    Abbadon
    Action
    Activism
    Adam's Family
    Adolescence
    Adolescence In Literature
    Adventure
    Afterlife
    Anne Rice
    Anubis
    Aprons
    ARC Readers
    A Room Of My Own
    Atropos
    Audio
    Author
    Author Interview
    Author Marketing
    Axis Trilogy
    Bad Ass Heroines
    Bad Santa
    Balance
    Batman
    Bats
    Becoming A Mom
    Beetlejuice
    Belief
    Belle
    Big Bad Wolves
    Blogging
    Blog Hop
    Blog Tour
    Book Blast
    Book Blitz
    Book Collector
    Book Covers
    Book Deals
    Book Editing
    Book Hoarders
    Book Hoarding
    Book I Of The Dreamer
    Book Launc
    Book Reviews
    Books
    Book Sale
    Book Sharing
    Book Tour
    Book Trailer
    Book Trailers
    Booktrope
    Booktrope Closing
    Booktrope Publishing
    Boyfriends
    Boy Vs. Girl
    Broken Heart
    Buffy The Vampire Slayer
    Bunnicula
    Cait Reynolds
    Camelot
    Caroline B. Cooney
    Carrie Fisher
    Castle Battle
    Cellar Door Lit Rants And Reviews
    Change
    Changes
    Charles DiLaurentis
    Chicklit
    Children
    Children's Books
    Children's Lit
    Chirrut Imwe
    Chris Hemsworth
    Christmas
    Christmas Presents
    Christopher Pike
    Cinder
    Cinderella
    CINDY
    Classics
    Cleaning
    Clutch
    College Dreams
    Comic-Con
    Contemporary Women's Lit
    Copyright Infringement
    Costume Ideas
    Crafts
    Crafts For Kids
    Creative Non-fiction
    Cyrborgs
    Dancing
    Darth Vader
    Deals
    Death
    Death Deities
    Death Star
    Decor
    Decorating
    Decorations
    Defining
    Deities
    Demeter
    Diaries
    Dislike Button
    Disney
    Disney Princesses
    Dogs
    Doll House
    Downcast
    Dragon Moon Press
    Dragons
    Dream Diary
    Dreams
    Dystopian
    Eddie Justice
    Editing
    Egyptian God
    Election
    Elena Kincaid
    Elf On The Shelf
    Elsa
    English
    Epic Fantasy
    Erotica
    Escapism
    Eternal LIfe
    Excerpt
    Facebook
    Facebook Launch Party
    Facebook Pet Peeves
    Fae
    Fairies
    Fairytale Lost
    Fairytale Retelling
    Fairytales
    Fairy Tales
    Faith
    Fandom
    Fandom Terminology
    Fangirl
    Fantasy
    Fantasy Art
    Fantasycon
    Fantasy Fiction
    Fantasy-Fiction
    Felicity Jones
    Feminism
    Feminists
    First Love
    Fisher Price Little People
    Fitness
    Flash Fiction
    Flip The Flap Books
    Florida
    Force Awakens
    Fractured Dream
    Fractured Dream Soundtrack
    Free Books
    Freyja
    Friendship
    Frozen
    Gandalf
    Gay Rights
    Gener Roles
    Getting Older
    Ghosts
    Ghost Stories
    Girl Power
    Giveaway
    Giveaways
    Goals
    Go Ask Alice
    Greek Mythology
    Greek Myths
    Grim Reaper
    Grim's Fall
    Grim's Fall: Part III
    Growing Apart
    Growth
    Hades
    Haiku
    Halloween
    Harry Potter
    Health
    Heartbreak
    Hero
    Heroine
    Heroines
    Hindu Deities
    Hindu Gods
    Holly Black
    Home Office
    Homosexual Themes
    Hope
    Horror
    Horror High
    House Of Night
    Human Rights
    Humble Bundle
    Ideas
    Ignorance
    Imaginary Friends
    Imagination
    Indigo-Ashe Book Trailers
    Inner Voice
    Inspiration
    Inspiring Women
    Insta-love
    International Women's Day
    Invisible Friends
    Irish Times
    Jackie Paper
    Jake And The Neverland Pirates
    Jayme Beddingfield
    Jyn Erso
    K-2SO
    Kali
    Katrina Mendolera
    Katrina M. Mendolera
    Katrina M. Randall
    Katrina Randall
    Kickstarter
    Kids
    Kindness
    K.m. Randall
    K.M. Randall
    KM Randall
    K. Williams
    Kylo Ren
    Larry WIlson
    Legends
    Leia
    Library
    Life After Death
    Lingo
    Literary Characters
    Literature
    Little Boys
    Little Girls
    Little Red Riding Hood
    LJ Smith
    Lord Of The Rings
    Losing Friends
    Louise Cooper
    Love
    Love Triangles
    Lunar Chronicles
    Magic
    Magics
    Making A Book Trailer
    Marissa Meyer
    Mark Zuckerberg
    Mary-sue
    Mermaid Summer
    Mexican Day Of The Dead
    Mexican Folk Saint
    Miley Cyrus
    Moms
    Monday Blogs
    Motherhood
    Mrs. Piggle Wiggle
    Music
    Muslims
    My First Superman Books
    My Son
    Mythology
    Myths
    National Tell A Fairytale Day
    New Roads
    New Year
    Norse
    Occult
    October Frights Blog Hop
    Olympus Falling
    Omar Mateen
    One Flew Over The Cukoos Nest
    Orlando
    OTP
    Ouija Board
    Paranormal
    Parenthood
    Parents
    Part II
    Paul And Mary
    Peppa Pig
    Perceptions
    Persephone
    Personal Growth
    Peter
    Peter Yarrow
    PLL Theories
    Poems
    Poetry
    Poetry About Children
    Prequel
    Pretty Little Liars
    Pretty Little Liar Theories
    Publishing
    Publishing Industry
    Puff The Magic Dragon
    Quirky Book Sirens
    Rafflecopter
    Rafflecopter Giveaway
    Rant
    Rap Battles
    Rasputina
    Reading
    Reading For Life
    Realism
    Reality
    Reality TV
    Reapers
    Rebel
    Rebellions
    Refurbishing Dollhouse
    Relationships
    Release Date
    Repurposing
    Research
    Resistance
    Resolutions
    Restaurants
    Retelling
    Retellings
    Review
    Reviews
    Rey
    Richie Tankersley Cusick
    R.L. Stine
    RL Stine
    Rogue One
    Rogue One Review
    Romance
    Ruby Dawson Saga
    Running
    Rylee Adamson
    Sale
    Santa
    Santa Clause
    Santa Muerte
    Sara Douglass
    School Dreams
    Science-fiction
    Secret Circle
    Serving
    Sex
    Sexual Content
    Sharing Meaning
    Shattered World
    Sheilah Randall
    Shipping
    Short Story
    Sir Edwin Arnold
    Siren Publishing
    Sisters
    Skepticism
    Slices Of Mommy's Life
    Snow White
    Social Media
    Songs
    Soul Mates
    Soundtrack
    Speculative Fiction
    Spooky
    Star Wars
    Stephen King
    Stop The Hate
    Strong Female Characters
    Strong Females
    Superheroes
    Super Heroes
    Superman
    Supernatural
    Sword
    Symbolism
    Tarod
    Teenage Friendships
    Teenagers
    Teen Horror
    Teen WItch
    The Craft
    The Darkest Part Of The Forest
    The Dreamer Saga
    The Dreamer Trilogy
    The Golden Fiddle
    The Grim's Fall
    The Highly Capable
    The Last Jedi
    The Lemonade Trick
    The Reaper's Daughter
    The Reaper's Daughter
    The Reape's Daughter
    The Shadow Soul
    Thor
    Three Fates
    Time Master Trilogy
    Toddler Books
    Tolkien
    Trailokya Trilogy #1
    Transylvania Concubine
    Tressla
    True Love
    Twilight
    Twisted Fairytales
    Twitter Blast
    Underworld
    Unshattered
    Valentine's Day
    Vampire
    Vampire Diaries
    VC Andrews
    Vlog
    Voices
    Waitressing
    Wattpad
    Web Series
    Who Is A?
    Wicca
    Witches
    Witch Week
    Woman Power
    Women
    Women In Lit
    Women In Movies
    Women's Rights
    Wonderwoman
    Wonder Woman
    Workaholic
    Writing
    YA
    Young Adult

    Tweets by @KM_Randall
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Books
    • Fractured Dream
    • Shattered World
    • The Reaper's Daughter
    • Song of the Scythe
    • Tattered Fairytale
  • Author
    • Best Seller Rankings
    • Media
  • Quirky Book Sirens
  • Contact Me
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Books
    • Fractured Dream
    • Shattered World
    • The Reaper's Daughter
    • Song of the Scythe
    • Tattered Fairytale
  • Author
    • Best Seller Rankings
    • Media
  • Quirky Book Sirens
  • Contact Me